Lessig & Tweedy: The Right to Rip, Mix & Burn

David Carr Larry Lessig & Wilco’s Jeff Tweedy spoke at the NY Public Library last week:

The tickets for the event Thursday sold out in five minutes on the Internet, and on the evening itself the lines stretched down the block. The reverent young fans might as well have been holding cellphones aloft as totems of their fealty.

Then again, this was the New York Public Library, a place of very high ceilings and even higher cultural aspirations, so the rock concert vibe created some dissonance. Inside, things became clearer as two high priests of very different tribes came together to address the question of “Who Owns Culture?” – a discussion of digital file-sharing sponsored by Wired magazine, part of a library series called “Live From the NYPL.”

Both Jeff Tweedy, the leader of the fervently followed rock band Wilco, and Lawrence Lessig, a Stanford University law professor who has opposed criminalizing file sharing, seemed to agree that just about anybody who owns a modem also owns – or at least has every right to download – culture products.

Audio archive is available on Wilco’s web site.

Sensenbrenner & The Patriot Act Renewal

Craig Gilbert:

Most of the debate involves a handful of the new powers, such as government access to personal records from medical offices, libraries and businesses.
Sensenbrenner suggested that most of the 16 temporary powers could be made permanent, but that a few would remain subject to a sunset, or expiration date.
“I think it’s evident . . . there’s not going to be a repeal of the sunset,” Sensenbrenner said, referring to the fact that even some Republicans on his committee oppose making all the expiring provisions permanent.

Top Big Brother Picks

Joanna Glasner:

Two major data brokers, a California elementary school and Google’s Gmail service are leading contenders for the Big Brother Awards — a dubious prize spotlighting organizations with egregious privacy practices.
Award recipients will receive a statue of a golden boot stomping on a human head.
The nominees were among those on a list made public Wednesday by Privacy International, the British watchdog group that runs the annual U.S. Big Brother Awards. The group plans to announce winners on April 14.

Wispolitics Budget Blog

Useful links & commentary on the state budget “process”….

“$310 million – we could buy a boat for everyone in the state to get across the river.?
— JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald on the cost of the proposed Stillwater Bridge spanning the St. Croix River between Wisconsin and Minnesota in northwest Wisconsin.
?This is a very technical Web site. This is not just Mapquest.?
— DOT Secretary Frank Busalacchi defending the cost of a $650,000 interactive site for the Marquette Interchange.

Air Wisconsin Loses United Airlines/Express Contract

Thomas Daykin:

United Airlines “was trying to put the squeeze on Air Wisconsin” when it put that business up for bid, said Michael Boyd, president of Boyd Group Inc., an aviation industry consulting firm in Evergreen, Colo.
He said United’s executives probably figured they could force Air Wisconsin to cut the prices it charges United Airlines to keep that business.
“Air Wisconsin ruined that little game” when it reached the agreement to provide financing to US Airways in return for getting a piece of its regional carrier business, Boyd said.

I think United might, perhaps be squeezing too hard (perhaps they have no choice). Having recently flown through Chicago, it seems that American’s regional jet operation is less chaotic…..

California’s Housing Boom – How long?

David Streitfeld:

Herron put no money down for her tidy one-bedroom, borrowing the entire purchase price of $211,000. To keep her monthly payments as low as possible, she got an adjustable-rate mortgage that won’t require her to pay any principal for three years.
Thanks to her “interest-only” loan, the 911 police dispatcher was able to afford, barely, her first home. She now has a stake in California’s sizzling real estate market. As her home increases in value, she plans to use some of that equity to pay down her credit cards.

Time for a Value Added Tax (VAT)?

Bruce Bartlett:

GROWING numbers of policy analysts and politicians are saying that it may finally be time to consider a value-added tax as part of our federal revenue system. In years past, I would have been in the forefront of those denouncing the idea. But now, reluctantly, I have joined the pro-V.A.T. side. Here’s why.
There are many arguments against a value-added tax, which is essentially a sales tax that applies at each stage of production. It is costly to put into effect, and it hits the poor and the elderly hardest because they spend a higher percentage of their income.

Gordon Moore on 40 Years of Moore’s Law

Michael Kanellos:

When you look back, what products have inspired you to say, “Wow, that’s a beautiful piece of work?”
Moore: Well, the ones I think of as landmarks were not necessarily beautiful pieces of work, but they turned out to be economically viable. The first dynamic RAM we made at Intel is with that category–the old 1103. It was a 1K DRAM and that was our first really big-revenue product. I guess I have to put the first microprocessor in that category too. It was very slow, but it did the job that it was designed to do. There’ve been a lot of things since that have been very important economically. I tend to think of them as more evolutionary products.